Action 4 Botton

Action for Botton

This was the text of the leaflet informing the public about Botton's problems with its charity and the launch of Action for Botton June 2014

Here is a printable version of the leaflet with the same content as PDF

This beautiful and caring community of volunteer families and learning disabled people is being destroyed by the very body that should be fostering and supporting it. 

What is Botton?

For nearly 60 years, Botton Village has provided a sustainable way of living with adults with a learning disability in a community where all work according to their abilities, supported where necessary by the vocational volunteer families known as co-workers with whom they can live in shared family-like homes.  This Camphill community was founded on the principles of Rudolf Steiner and has offered happy confident homes very different from most private or local authority providers.  It helps that it is at the head of a beautiful dale in the North York Moors and over the years has established its organic farms, bakery, creamery, wood-workshop and other places where villagers contribute as they can. 

Why is it now threatened?

Together with the Camphill Village Trust (CVT), Botton co-workers were making tremendous efforts to adapt to the requirements of current social care legislation. Although this has been successful and co-workers thought they were working in partnership with CVT, its chair and chief executive told them on 13 May 2014 that all co-workers had to leave the village community in the coming months unless they applied to become employed staff. However, employees would need to live separate from the villagers or outside the village. A thriving community where people with and without disabilities have been living and working together happily and like equals is being taken apart and restructured to become a managed provider of housing and support for the disabled. CVT said they needed to do this for tax reasons, which is, particularly in respect of Botton, heavily contested by other legal and tax advice.

How can they do this?

We now know that a small group of officials at the top of CVT has taken extraordinary steps to control the charity and its membership. In 2012 they managed to alter the charity constitution by threatening every member with expulsion if they voted against a key proposal, as a consequence of which the board now has only independent trustees and nobody left to represent Camphill co-workers and their values. They have also been barring people from becoming new members of the charity if they were even related to co-workers or simply expressed support for the Camphill principles of community living, effectively engineering the voting membership list in favour of their stated reform plans. As a consequence, a few individuals with seemingly no sympathy for Camphill life have now 'taken over' this great charity.

Having silenced and disempowered the vocational co-workers in their own charity, the operational team is now in the process of eliminating them altogether. Many co-workers now feel very vulnerable, and co-workers who do not declare allegiance to CVT's plans (80% of Botton's co-workers) have been stripped of their community management roles. These and other controversial actions of the current CVT leadership have now caused deep fear and mistrust in their communities.

Why is that so bad?

Essential to Camphill communities are the long-term co-workers, those families who share their lives and homes, work with and support people in need, as a vocational commitment, out of love. Life-sharing and voluntary commitment clearly was what Karl König had in mind when he founded the Camphill Village Trust in October 1954.  “We are convinced that we could not do our work in the same manner if we were employees and received a salary, because we know that work that is paid loses its social value.” To help them realise this vision the Macmillan family offered König and CVT their Botton Hall and surrounding farms in the Danby Dale in 1955.

Three core principles have created the successful, enduring and stable body of Camphill. They are: voluntary commitment, shared living and meaningful work. The beauty and purpose, recognised by so many who have come into contact with Camphill, lie within these three interwoven and interdependent principles. Importantly, Camphill communities are intentional self-directing communities, whilst CVT has established an operational team that has taken full control in managing more and more employed staff, the signature of a typical social care provider but not a Camphill community of people living together. The sad reality is that Karl König, the man who founded the Camphill Village Trust, would no doubt be rejected if he asked to become a member of the charity today, and would by now have received a letter from CVT asking him to leave Botton.

Surely the co-workers should be working with CVT?

There was no attempt by CVT to have a meaningful discussion with the co-workers, nor with the supported adults, their relatives, or others directly involved.  However, a recent consultation process commissioned by CVT told them that the people supported and their families were overwhelmingly in favour of the vocational co-worker and life sharing model. The co-workers, despite their shock at the bombshell dropped on 13 May, have pleaded with CVT to stop their intended course and start working with those actually at Botton to find a better solution. This has not happened and CVT refuse to disclose documents on which their decision is based.

One is left asking why CVT is dismantling this much loved community based on volunteer life sharing.  What is clear is that they intend to ignore that this plan runs against the principles under which the charity was established and by which they should feel themselves bound.  In the current climate, most co-workers feel besieged and intimidated by the way CVT uses control and ultimata.  It is only after the failure of every attempt to engage CVT that this public appeal is launched.  Without your positive and immediate help and support the Botton many know and love and which has been a beacon of sharing and caring in this world will no longer exist.


Built by Jack Barber in Whitby, North Yorkshire. Visit Herbal Apothecary for herbal practitioner supplies, Sweet Cecily's for natural skincare and Future Health Store for whole foods, health supplements, natural & ethical gifts.